Pages

▼

Thursday, October 11, 2007

A Review of The Race Set Before Us

Kevin McFadden reviews The Race Set Before Us.

A few things in the review prompt me to smile. One of those is the attempt to do source criticism, venturing who wrote which chapters. It seems that Tom and I must have done a fairly good job veiling who wrote each chapter.

at

2 comments:

  1. Drew Hunter10/22/07, 9:37 AM

    I had done similar "source criticism" on my reading. I came with similar conclusions.
    2, 4, 5: Schreiner
    3, 7, 8: Caneday

    1 and 6 were left open for future research, although I lean towards Schreiner on 1 because of his past article that covered similar ground.

    ReplyDelete
  2. abcaneday10/22/07, 1:00 PM

    Drew,

    We could make this a game, sort of like Mastermind. Here's a clue. Of the eight chapters, you correctly identified three.

    ReplyDelete

Please Take Note.

Comments are moderated. Your comments will not show immediately. So, be patient. There is no need to post again immediately on the assumption that your comment got lost in cyberspace. If comments are acceptable, they will be published.